Minutes
of Meeting In Board of Trustees
Trustees’ Capital Projects Committee
Wednesday, January 7, 2004
A meeting of the
Trustees’ Capital Projects Committee was held in the Trustees’
Room of the Johnson Building at 11:00 a.m.
Present at the
meeting were: The Honorable Angelo M. Scaccia; President Bernard
A. Margolis; Alice Hennessey, Special Assistant to Mayor Thomas
M. Menino; Kathleen Kirleis, Chief Financial Officer; Robert Flynn,
Facilities Officer; Edward Maheigan, Budget and Procurement Manager;
and Jamie McGlone, Clerk to the Trustees.
Chairman Angelo
M. Scaccia presiding.
The first item
on the order of business was the approval of Minutes for the Trustees’
Capital Projects Committee Meeting on November 6, 2003. On a motion
duly made and seconded, the Minutes for the Trustees’ Capital
Projects Committee Meeting on November 6, 2003 were approved.
President Bernard
A. Margolis provided an update on the status and progress of the
McKim Restoration project, Phase IIC which has commenced with the
renovation of several significant public spaces including: the original
Trustees’ Room, the Cheverus Room, the Abbey Room, the Sargent
Gallery, and the Exhibit Room located on the first floor of the
McKim building.
In addition, the
restoration of the priceless murals by John Singer Sargent is progressing
by the conservators from Straus Center for Conservation at the Harvard
University Art Museums, which are slated to be completed by February
2004, along with renovation work to the Cheverus Room and the Edwin
Austin Abbey Room. The Sargent Gallery staging is scheduled to be
removed on January 19, 2004 in preparation for the renovation work
to commence in the Abbey Room.
The project scope
for McKim Restoration, Phase IIC also includes the renovation of
the McKim fifth floor, the installation of a new elevator for greater
accessibility to the Abbey Foyer, the installation of a new book
conveyor system, the installation of new restrooms and the upgrading
of the current restrooms, window restoration, electrical and mechanical
work, as well as furnishing of the McKim Lobby and the original
Trustees’ Room.
The architectural
services for McKim Phase IIC are being provided by Shepley, Bulfinch,
Richardson & Abbott, Inc. and the contractor for the project
is Lee Kennedy Company.
With regard to
McKim Phase IIC project schedule and financing, the construction
for the next phase of the McKim project is estimated to cost $14.3
million and is slated to be substantially completed by May 25, 2004,
including the background work on the heating, air conditioning,
mechanical and electrical portions of the project, in preparation
for the restoration of the Abbey and Sargent Gallery murals and
related building artwork.
On the financial
front, funding for the project is in place at the City Treasury
and is estimated at a total project budget of $20.4 million, including
the transfer of the $7.5 million from the State-funded match as
a result of the City’s advance of $1.2 million, which has
been fully reimbursed to the City of Boston. The project budget
also includes funding for architectural services provided by Shepley,
Bulfinch, Richardson & Abbott, Inc. coupled with additional
costs related to signage, artwork restoration, furnishings and a
contingency reserve fund.
Meanwhile, preliminary
planning efforts have commenced for the next phase of the project,
McKim Restoration project, Phase IID. To further those ends, the
Library has begun internal discussions, walk throughs, and processes
pertaining to the development of the project scope for McKim Phase
IID coupled with a preliminary review of the capital funds which
would need to be raised for the project.
The project scope
under consideration for Phase IID will include the renovation of
five primary public spaces, including the Print Gallery, Music and
Fine Arts Departments, the Rare Books and Manuscripts Department,
and the Map Center on the McKim third floor. The project scope and
related timetable for Phase IID will be crafted by utilizing the
Master Plan for the Central Library which was developed by Hardy
Holzman Pfeiffer Associates.
While the project
schedule and timetable have not yet been developed for Phase IID,
they will be driven in part by fundraising efforts and by Phase
IIC’s projected total completion date of July 2004. In addition,
the Library would anticipate seeking funding for Phase IID with
a heavy reliance on potential individual donors and federal sources
estimated at a total project budget of $25 million.
The fundraising
strategy under consideration for Phase IID would be to compartmentalize
activities targeted to individuals and constituencies who would
have specific and particular interests around the collections and
services provided by the five primary Library departments slated
for renovation.
Meanwhile, the
2004 Boston Public Library Foundation Gala has been scheduled for
Friday, May 7, 2004 in the McKim building to benefit the McKim Restoration
project. The Committee members suggested that tours of the McKim
Restoration project spaces for both Phases IIC and IID be incorporated
into the Gala program.
To further that
end, fundraising efforts for Phase IID have begun noting that the
City of Boston has granted permission for the Library to utilize
part of the funds raised by the Boston Public Library Foundation
through the Department of the Interior’s National Parks Service
“Save America’s Treasures” program to be earmarked
for Phase IID totaling $470,000. In addition, the Boston Public
Library is in receipt of a gift from an estate totaling $150,000
and the Foundation has submitted a grant proposal for $2.5 million
which will be slated for Phase IID.
In a review of
additional capital projects, President Margolis reported that the
Sebastians Map Room Café and Novel Restaurant renovation
projects have been successfully completed and that the food and
catering services operations have gotten off to a great start. The
two operations have received great reviews on both the quality of
food and on the ambiance of the renovated spaces. In addition, the
improvements to the acoustics in both spaces, which were approved
by the Landmarks Commission along with other changes, have proved
to be very successful particularly with the installation of the
new rug in the Café.
President Margolis
provided an update and status report on the progress of the Johnson
Building capital projects, including significant upgrades slated
for the Johnson Building Fire Alarm System, in which bids are expected
to be issued mid-February 2004 with construction scheduled to start
early winter 2004. Upon completion of the upgrades slated for July
2004, the Johnson Building fire alarm system would remain separate
from the McKim fire alarm system with access to communication between
both buildings remaining available.
Additionally, the
President provided an update on the completion of the Copley Square
Water Main replacement of the 42-inch water pipe that caused the
BPL flood. Meanwhile, the extensive excavation has been filled and
all systems appear to be operating appropriately.
In other ongoing
Library capital projects, the South End Branch Library Window Replacement
project has been completed while additional branch repairs are continuing.
Meanwhile, the bids for the McKim Basement Repairs and the Flood
Recovery program are on track. The bids were issued late October
2003 with a bid due date of January 15, 2004 and calls for a substantial
project completion date by June 30, 2004.
President Margolis
distributed a capital projects update on the progress impacting
eighteen different branches in various phases of capital work and
reviewed their current project status. Among the projects highlighted,
Facilities Officer Robert Flynn reported that planning efforts are
underway for exterior renovations at the Codman Square, Grove Hall
and Lower Mills Branch Libraries noting that a contract has been
awarded with an anticipated project starting date on January 19,
2004.
Meanwhile, construction
is underway for renovations to the Roslindale Branch while a starting
date for renovations to the South Boston Branch has yet to be determined.
The current plan by the contractor for the capital projects, BC
Construction, is to complete renovations to the Roslindale Branch
first, then move to the South Boston Branch phase of construction.
Initial work at the Roslindale Branch will focus on the skylight
and roof followed by the installation of new energy efficient windows.
The President reported
that the December snows and rains forced the Library to close the
Brighton Branch Library to the public on December 18, 2003 prior
to the commencement of a long-planned roofing project. Extensive
interior damage resulting from the 24-inch snowstorm has complicated
attempts to proceed with the work and to put the branch back into
business.
Meanwhile, it is
projected to be several months before the re-roofing work and cleaning
the interior of the facility is completed. Further, an assessment
will be undertaken of all the Library roofs which are older than
ten years and a request will be made to replace those roofs in next
year’s capital planning budget.
On the collaborative
front, the Boston Public Library and the Boston Parks Department
are working in concert to address ADA accessibility improvements
at the Parker Hill Branch by having the entrance to an unobtrusive
handicap access ramp start in the park adjacent to the Library.
To further that end, the project is currently in the design development
phase in anticipation of going out to bid mid-January 2004 pending
resolution of financial issues.
On the Branch Library
development front, the program statement work has been completed
as part of the siting studies for the Mattapan and Uphams Corner
Branch Libraries by the firm of Schwartz, Silver Architects, but
in light of budgetary constraints, the Library is not proceeding
at this time with the site selection work to identify potential
sites for new branch libraries earmarked for both communities.
Meanwhile, a contract
has been awarded and construction is underway for major roof repairs
and ADA accessibility improvements at the Connolly Branch Library.
Further, preparations for Roof Repairs at four Branches, Dudley,
East Boston, Egleston, and Orient Heights, are in process and currently
in the design phase with construction projected to start February
2004.
Mr. Flynn reported
that construction is currently underway and on track for a variety
of capital improvements to the Faneuil and Jamaica Plain Branches,
which is being funded in part with a grant received from the Massachusetts
Historic Commission. The renovations at both branches are primarily
focused on roof repairs, repointing and refurbishment of interior
surfaces while window replacements at the Faneuil Branch are slated
to be installed late January 2004.
Mr. Edward Maheigan
shared with the Committee members a list of the ongoing and completed
Critical Repair Fund Projects for FY 2004 reflecting a total annual
budget of $250,000 earmarked for smaller capital projects not exceeding
$25,000. Included among the critical repair projects highlighted
were roof and bathroom repairs, boiler conversions from oil to gas,
replacement lighting and wiring, environmental testing, and the
installation of sound attenuators in the Johnson building to reduce
exterior noise from the Library’s mechanical systems.
Mr. Maheigan reported
that the Budget Office has allowed the Library to carryover $148,637
from the FY 2003 critical repair budget reflecting a total budget
of $398,637 available for FY 2004. To date, critical repair capital
projects totaling $370,509 have been committed to or are in process
for FY 2004.
Facilities Officer
Robert Flynn provided an overview of the critical repair capital
projects successfully completed for FY 2004 noting that the repairs
to the front doors of the West Roxbury Branch have been completed
along with the electrical upgrades and replacement lighting to the
Kirstein Business Branch. In addition, the oil tank has been removed
at the Parker Hill Branch due to a gas heating conversion project.
Meanwhile, new
handicap front doors at the Mattapan Branch and at the South Street
side entrance to the Jamaica Plain Branch are in the process of
being installed while the installation of a similar door for the
front entrance to the North End Branch has been completed.
In a review of
the critical repair projects slated for FY 2004, Mr. Flynn reported
that the following capital projects are underway: air conditioning
unit replacements at the Charlestown and Codman Square Branches;
repairs to the McKim Building’s Dartmouth Street platform
and marble flooring in the Courtyard; and repairs to the freight
elevator in the Johnson Building.
Mr. Flynn recalled
that mold was detected in the Central Library, Charlestown Service
building, and the New England Deposit Library facility resulting
from the high humidity this past summer season. The mold clean-up
at NEDL, which involves the BPL and Harvard, will be covered by
the NEDL accounts while funds from the critical repair budget for
FY 2004 will cover the ongoing clean-up at the Central Library and
the Charlestown Service building.
In other business,
Ms. Alice Hennessey suggested that the Library explore alternative
resources for maintaining the landscaping and lawn mowing the grounds
at the Branch Libraries given the budgetary constraints facing the
City, including the use of volunteers and Friends’ groups
pairing with local neighborhood garden clubs.
Ms. Hennessey provided
an update on the ongoing efforts being made toward the potential
site selection and acquisition of property for the development of
the Boston Heritage Center. Construction of the storage facility
would provide for the appropriate storage conditions for the Boston
Public Library and the City Archives archival and retrospective
collections as well as providing convenient public access within
the City to these vast collections.
Ms. Kathleen Kirleis, Chief Financial Officer, reported that the
Library is in the process of interviewing three finalists, all with
both Library and construction experience, for the City approved
Capital Construction Project Manager’s position at the Boston
Public Library in anticipation of filling the position by the next
Committee meeting.
Chairman Scaccia
scheduled the next Trustees’ Capital Projects Committee meeting
for Wednesday, February 25, 2004 at 10:00 a.m. The Chairman asked
that a tour of the McKim Restoration project, Phase IIC and Phase
IID spaces be placed on the agenda for the next meeting. There being
no further business, the meeting of the Trustees’ Capital
Projects Committee adjourned at 12 noon.
Respectfully submitted,
Jamie McGlone
Clerk to the Trustees
|