Minutes
of the November 4, 2002 meeting
Minutes of Meeting
In Board of Trustees
Trustees Capital
Projects Committee
A meeting of the
Trustees Capital Projects Committee was held in the Trustees
Room of the Johnson Building at 10:00 a.m.
Present at the meeting
were: Trustee Berthé M. Gaines; President Bernard A. Margolis;
Alice Hennessey, Special Assistant to Mayor Menino; Charles Worcester,
Assistant Director, Division of Capital Construction; P.A. dArbeloff,
Communications Officer; Kathleen Kirleis, Chief Financial Officer;
Robert Flynn, Facilities Officer; Marie Pettibone, Executive Director,
and Susan Clarke, Development Director, the Boston Public Library
Foundation; Edward Maheigan, Budget and Procurement Manager; and
Jamie McGlone, Clerk to the Trustees.
Trustee Berthé
M. Gaines presiding.
The first item on
the order of business was the approval of Minutes for the Trustees
Capital Projects Committee Meeting on September 4, 2002. On a motion
duly made and seconded, the Minutes for the Trustees Capital
Projects Committee Meeting on September 4, 2002 were approved.
Mr. Charles Worcester
provided an update on the status of the McKim Restoration project,
Phase IIB (Courtyard/Roof) which is 100% complete. Subsequent
to the last Capital Projects Committee meeting, Mr. Worcester reported
that two previously outstanding punch list items were successfully
completed, including the restoration and installation of several
flag pole brackets located on the façade of the McKim building
and final closure on Phase IIB financing.
Mr. Charles Worcester
also reported on the status of the McKim Restoration project,
Phase IIC project scope, schedule and financing which has commenced
and will include the renovation of several significant public spaces:
including the original Trustees Room, the Cheverus Room, the
Abbey Room and the Sargent Gallery in addition to the restoration
of the priceless murals by John Singer Sargent and Edwin Austin
Abbey.
President Margolis
noted that the restoration work on the Sargent Gallery murals by
the conservators from Straus Center for Conservation at the Harvard
University Art Museums is slated to begin today and offered
to lead the Committee members on a tour of the Sargent Gallery following
the meeting. The President said that the Committee would also be
given a tour and overview of the proposed design development plans
for the McKim Map Room Café and Tea Room which is
expected to be fully operational by early spring 2003.
The project scope
for McKim Restoration, Phase IIC also includes the renovation
of the McKim fifth floor, the installation of a new elevator for
greater accessibility to the Abbey Foyer, the installation of a
new book conveyor system, the installation of new restrooms and
the upgrading of the current restrooms, window restoration, electrical
and mechanical work, as well as furnishing of the McKim Lobby and
the original Trustees Room.
The architectural
services for McKim Phase IIC are being provided by Shepley,
Bulfinch, Richardson & Abbott, Inc. The contractor for the
project is Lee Kennedy Company, and the Straus Center
for Conservation at the Harvard University Art Museums is overseeing
the restoration of the murals.
With regard to McKim
Phase IIC project schedule and financing, the construction for
the next phase of the McKim project is estimated to cost $14.3 million
and is slated to be completed by May 2004, including the background
work on the heating, air conditioning, mechanical and electrical
portions of the project in preparation for the restoration of the
Abbey and Sargent Gallery murals and related building artwork.
On the financial
front, funding for the project is in place at the City Treasury
and is estimated at a total project budget of $20.4 million, including
the transfer of the $7.5 million from the State-funded match as
a result of the Citys advance of $1.2 million, which has been
fully reimbursed to the City of Boston. The project budget also
includes funding for architectural services provided by Shepley,
Bulfinch, Richardson & Abbott, Inc. coupled with additional
costs related to signage, artwork restoration, furnishings and a
contingency reserve fund.
The Chief Financial
Officer reported that the Boston Public Library has received formal
notification that the BPL has been awarded a Save Americas
Treasures grant totaling $470,000 through the National Parks
Services. The grant award will be applied to the McKim Restoration
project, Phase IIC project budget and an equal amount will be
reprogrammed toward the next phase of the McKim project.
President Margolis
provided an update on the beginning planning efforts for the next
phase of the project, McKim Restoration project, Phase IID.
The President noted that the Library has begun internal discussions
and processes pertaining to the development of the project scope
for McKim Phase IID coupled with a preliminary review of the capital
funds which would need to be raised for the project.
The President reported
that the project scope under consideration for Phase IID will include
the renovation of several significant public spaces, including the
Print, Music and Fine Arts Departments along with the Rare Books
and Manuscripts Department and the Map area on the McKim third floor.
In response to an
inquiry from Ms. Hennessey, the President reported that the project
schedule and timetable has not yet been established for Phase IID,
which will be driven in part by fundraising efforts and by Phase
IICs projected completion date of May 2004. The CFO added
that the Library would anticipate seeking funding for Phase IID
in the Citys Capital budget request for FY 2005.
Trustee Gaines inquired
about the status of the McKim Map Room Café and Tea Room
project and whether the renovation plans would include improving
the acoustics in both spaces. The President reported that the Library
has engaged an acoustical engineer to address improving the acoustics
in the two rooms. Meanwhile, the Request for Proposals (RFP) for
the project has been advertised, which includes soliciting local
caterers to participate in the bid process, and then having the
selected vendor work collaboratively with the architect designer
to develop the café and tea room spaces.
In other ongoing
capital projects, Mr. Worcester reported on the progress being made
on the South End Branch Library Window Replacement project
noting that the Division of Capital Construction has received several
revised proposals from the contractor for window replacement which
currently are under review by the project architect.
On the Branch Libraries
capital projects front, the President provided an update on the
progress of projects impacting eighteen different branches in various
phases of capital work. Of particular note, the President reported
that the program work has been completed as part of the siting studies
underway for the Mattapan and Uphams Corner Branch Libraries
by the firm of Schwartz, Silver Architects but the Library
is not proceeding at this time with the site selection work to identify
potential sites for new branch libraries earmarked for both communities
in light of budgetary constraints.
In addition, the
President reported that there are issues around the vapor barrier
and wood cladding at the new Allston Branch Library which
are presently being addressed by the Division of Capital Construction.
Meanwhile, the Allston Branch Library has been honored with
an award by the Boston Society of Architects> and the New England
Association of the American Institute of Architects (AIA) and has
been recommended for an award from the National AIA, which the Hyde
Park Branch Library
Further, the President
reported that preparations are underway for exterior renovation
work at the Codman Square, Grove Hall and Lower
Mills Branch Libraries which presently are in the design development
phase with a projected bid due date by mid February 2003. Renovations
to the South Boston and Roslindale Branches are also
in the design development phase with a projected bid due date by
March 2003 while bids for major renovations to the Parker Hill
Branch are due mid-May 2003.
Meanwhile, the President
noted that bids are due late winter 2003 for major roof repairs
and ADA accessibility improvements at the Connolly Branch Library
while a projected due date of mid-February 2003 has been established
for a variety of capital improvements to the Faneuil and
Jamaica Plain Branches, which will be funded in part from
a grant received from the Massachusetts Historic Commission.
Mr. Edward Maheigan
shared with the Committee members a list of the ongoing Critical
Repair Fund Projects for FY 2003 reflecting a total annual budget
of $250,000 and earmarked for smaller capital projects not exceeding
$25,000, including roof and bathroom repairs, boiler replacements,
environmental testing, and the installation of sound attenuators
in the Johnson building to reduce exterior noise from the Librarys
mechanical systems. To date, Mr. Maheigan reported that critical
repair capital projects totaling $167,000 have been committed to
or are in process for FY 2003.
Mr. Robert Flynn
reported on the projects successfully underway in the FY 2003 critical
repair fund program, which the City has renewed for a second fiscal
year, noting in particular that a HVAC unit replacement has been
ordered and will be installed soon at the Charlestown Branch
Library to replace the temporary heating unit that was recently
installed on an emergency basis. Meanwhile, renovations to the public
and staff bathrooms are underway at the East Boston and North
End Branch Libraries while a boiler replacement project is near
completion at the Codman Square Branch Library.
Trustee Gaines inquired
about the status of the proposed capital project to re-design and
improve the front entrance of the Dudley Branch Library.
The President replied that the program to enhance the Dudley Square
area remains under discussion pending availability of capital funding.
Ms. Marie Pettibone
announced that she will be leaving her position as Executive Director
of the Boston Public Library Foundation at the end of November 2002.
Ms. Pettibone introduced Ms. Susan Clarke who recently joined the
Foundation as Director of Development and who will serve as Acting
Executive Director during the search process for a new Executive
Director.
Ms. Pettibone reported
on the latest activities of the BPL Foundation noting that the Foundation
was instrumental in securing a Save Americas Treasures
grant totaling $470,000 from the National Parks Service earmarked
for the McKim project and a second grant totaling $500,000 for the
Sargent Murals Restoration project. Meanwhile, Ms. Pettibone encouraged
involvement of the Foundation Board members in the initial planning
efforts for McKim Phase IID which would be helpful around the future
fundraising tasks associated with the McKim project.
Trustee Gaines scheduled
the next Trustees Capital Projects Committee meeting for Tuesday,
January 7, 2003 at 10:00 a.m. There being no further business,
the meeting of the Trustees Capital Projects Committee adjourned
at 10:50 a.m.
Respectfully submitted,
Jamie McGlone
Clerk to the Trustees
|